In class on Monday we continue
talking about sex, gender, and sexuality. The class just finished talking about
sexuality and then a statement was brought up. According to McDonaugh and
Pappano, “We should not sort athletes by what sex they are, but rather by their
skill, interest, and ability in relation to the particular sports they wish to
play” (Mcdonaugh,2008,p. 10). After Dr. Spencer presented this statement she
had a few questions on this statement which included if we agreed or disagreed
with the statement and why or why not?
In my
opinion I do not necessarily agree with there statement. In some sports I can
see this being possible but in the same respect in others it wouldn’t. This
especially in the higher levels of sport because of the strength and speed of
the athletes. I don’t think many if any females would be able to reach the
level and some of the male athletes and this is not based of just a male’s perspective
because I know some females that would agree with me. In non contact sports
such as tennis or golf girls would be able to compete because it has been
proven but such contact sports such as football or soccer where natural speed
and strength is needed to compete day in and day out. I would like to see girls
compete at a higher level but I don’t see it happening just due strength and
speed and not talent because there are plenty of girls that have a lot of
talent and even more than guys.
My question
to whoever reads this is would you agree with my thoughts, and if you do is
there anything you would like to add? If you don’t agree please explain your
thoughts and maybe it would change my thoughts on this topic.
McDonagh,
E., & Pappano, L. (2008). What’s the problem? In Playing with the boys (pp. 1-37). Oxford, NY: Oxford University
Press.